San Francisco held its first "ranked-choice" elections on Tuesday, November 2, 2004, for seven of its eleven Board of Supervisors seats. The Department of Elections has released preliminary results and ballot details for the elections. The ballot details make it possible to replicate the "instant run-off" process, but also make some other interesting analysis possible.
I have performed three different kinds of tallies for these seven races to see what insights they might give. In the first tally, for each candidate the number of ballots giving that candidate as their first choice is counted. In the second tally, for each candidate the number of ballots giving that candidate as any choice—first, second, or third—is counted. In the third tally, for every pair of candidates, the number of ballots preferring one over the other is counted.
These alternative tallies are reminiscent of the election methods Plurality, Approval, and Condorcet. However, when actually used in an election, these different methods involve different kinds of ballots and different voter expectations and therefore can produce different results.
Interestingly, for all seven Board of Supervisors seats, all of the tallying methods I tried gave the same answer (by no means true in general). The instant run-off winner in each case had the plurality of first-choice votes anyway. Every incumbent running for re-election won (6 out of the 7 seats). Three won with first-choice majorities. The second-place candidate from the first-choice votes made it to the final elimination round of the instant run-off process in every case.
Comparing the different tallies does however reveal some interesting qualities of the voters' preferences. They enhance the role of minor candidates and hilight the degree to which exhausted ballots—those that don't rank the most popular candidates—could have affected the outcomes.
First, consider District One minor candidate Jeffrey S. Freebairn. He received a meager 127 first-choice votes and was unceremoniously eliminated in the first round of the instant run-off. But the any-choice tally shows that more than ten times as many voters, 1,417, gave Freebairn one of the three spots on their ballots, and the pairwise tally shows that fully 665 voters expressed a preference for Freebairn over Jake McGoldrick, the winner.
Next, consider District One frontrunners Jake McGoldrick and Lillian Sing. The pairwise tally shows that McGoldrick strongly beats every candidate except Sing, with a clear majority of voters expressing a preference for McGoldrick. While it also shows McGoldrick beating Sing, that is a weaker sort of victory because less than a majority of voters expressed a preference for McGoldrick. McGoldrick's margin of victory over Sing is 2,038 votes, but 4,782 ballots expressed no preference between these two candidates because neither candidate appeared among the top three choices on those ballots.
In District Nine, Tom Ammiano's pairwise tally is extremely strong. In the first-choice tally he got less than a majority of total ballots, and barely a majority of just those ballots showing at least one valid choice. But in the pairwise tally he shows a clear majority or supermajority of total ballots against every other candidate taken one at a time.
In District Five, on the other hand, Ross Mirkarimi doesn't show a majority of valid ballots preferring him over any other candidate in the pairwise tally. Only 22,342 out of 38,807 total ballots indicated any preference between Mirkarimi and Robert Haaland, the runner-up.
In the reports below, the "First Choice Tally" score for each candidate is the number of ballots on which that candidate appeared as the first choice. The "Any Choice Tally" score for each candidate is the number of ballots on which that candidate appeared as a first, second, or third choice. The "Pairwise Tally" gives two scores for every pair of candidates, the number of ballots where the first candidate was ranked higher than the second followed by the number of ballots where the second candidate was ranked higher than the first.
The percentages given below are in terms of the total ballots cast, not just the "total valid poll" (just the ballots with at least one valid choice) as the results are officially reported. This means that the percentages here are slightly lower that the official results. This does not affect any of the outcomes. §
District One
District Two
District Three
District Five
District Seven
District Nine
District Eleven
===== District One =====
Total ballots cast: 30360
Zero valid choices: 1956
One valid choice: 5558
Two valid choices: 3121
Three valid choices: 19725
* First Choice Tally
JAKE McGOLDRICK 38% 11655 <<< winner
DAVID HELLER 6% 1987
LEANNA DAWYDIAK 4% 1364
JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 0% 127
LILLIAN SING 29% 8877
ROSE TSAI 5% 1565
MATT TUCHOW 9% 2828
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Any Choice Tally
JAKE McGOLDRICK 56% 17117 <<< winner
DAVID HELLER 26% 8047
LEANNA DAWYDIAK 23% 7235
JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 4% 1417
LILLIAN SING 52% 16008
ROSE TSAI 24% 7397
MATT TUCHOW 45% 13753
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Pairwise Tally
JAKE McGOLDRICK <<< winner
vs. DAVID HELLER 16194 to 5127
vs. LEANNA DAWYDIAK 16393 to 4440
vs. JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 17044 to 665
vs. LILLIAN SING 13808 to 11770
vs. ROSE TSAI 16065 to 5496
vs. MATT TUCHOW 15371 to 7665
vs. WRITE-IN 17117 to 1
DAVID HELLER
vs. LEANNA DAWYDIAK 7102 to 5985
vs. JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 7926 to 985
vs. ROSE TSAI 7354 to 6781
vs. WRITE-IN 8047 to 1
LEANNA DAWYDIAK
vs. JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 7107 to 1191
vs. WRITE-IN 7235 to 1
JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN
vs. WRITE-IN 1417 to 1
LILLIAN SING
vs. DAVID HELLER 14907 to 5656
vs. LEANNA DAWYDIAK 15107 to 4899
vs. JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 15921 to 1199
vs. ROSE TSAI 14915 to 3371
vs. MATT TUCHOW 13743 to 8392
vs. WRITE-IN 16008 to 1
ROSE TSAI
vs. LEANNA DAWYDIAK 6867 to 6582
vs. JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 7315 to 1306
vs. WRITE-IN 7397 to 1
MATT TUCHOW
vs. DAVID HELLER 12112 to 6114
vs. LEANNA DAWYDIAK 12363 to 5381
vs. JEFFREY S. FREEBAIRN 13605 to 1051
vs. ROSE TSAI 12064 to 6209
vs. WRITE-IN 13753 to 1
===== District Two =====
Total ballots cast: 38702
Zero valid choices: 4990
One valid choice: 11251
Two valid choices: 3741
Three valid choices: 18720
* First Choice Tally
DAVID PASCAL 10% 4125
JAY R. SHAH 3% 1348
ROGER E. SCHULKE 4% 1918
MICHELA ALIOTO-PIER 53% 20653 <<< winner
STEVE BRACCINI 14% 5667
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Any Choice Tally
DAVID PASCAL 37% 14396
JAY R. SHAH 23% 9075
ROGER E. SCHULKE 25% 10060
MICHELA ALIOTO-PIER 66% 25883 <<< winner
STEVE BRACCINI 39% 15477
WRITE-IN 0% 2
* Pairwise Tally
DAVID PASCAL
vs. JAY R. SHAH 12837 to 6414
vs. ROGER E. SCHULKE 12249 to 7224
vs. WRITE-IN 14395 to 2
JAY R. SHAH
vs. WRITE-IN 9074 to 2
ROGER E. SCHULKE
vs. JAY R. SHAH 8555 to 7274
vs. WRITE-IN 10060 to 2
MICHELA ALIOTO-PIER <<< winner
vs. DAVID PASCAL 23689 to 7139
vs. JAY R. SHAH 24889 to 4308
vs. ROGER E. SCHULKE 24696 to 5322
vs. STEVE BRACCINI 23237 to 7817
vs. WRITE-IN 25883 to 1
STEVE BRACCINI
vs. DAVID PASCAL 12553 to 10349
vs. JAY R. SHAH 14121 to 6379
vs. ROGER E. SCHULKE 13856 to 6758
vs. WRITE-IN 15477 to 2
===== District Three =====
Total ballots cast: 28037
Zero valid choices: 2482
One valid choice: 7166
Two valid choices: 2461
Three valid choices: 15928
* First Choice Tally
AARON PESKIN 56% 15975 <<< winner
BRIAN MURPHY O'FLYNN 16% 4535
EUGENE CHI-CHING WONG 12% 3514
SAL BUSALACCHI 5% 1530
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Any Choice Tally
AARON PESKIN 72% 20360 <<< winner
BRIAN MURPHY O'FLYNN 54% 15404
EUGENE CHI-CHING WONG 43% 12229
SAL BUSALACCHI 42% 11876
WRITE-IN 0% 3
* Pairwise Tally
AARON PESKIN <<< winner
vs. BRIAN MURPHY O'FLYNN 17737 to 6766
vs. EUGENE CHI-CHING WONG 18394 to 6139
vs. SAL BUSALACCHI 18990 to 5064
vs. WRITE-IN 20360 to 3
BRIAN MURPHY O'FLYNN
vs. EUGENE CHI-CHING WONG 11560 to 7967
vs. SAL BUSALACCHI 12857 to 5311
vs. WRITE-IN 15402 to 2
EUGENE CHI-CHING WONG
vs. SAL BUSALACCHI 10185 to 8398
vs. WRITE-IN 12229 to 1
SAL BUSALACCHI
vs. WRITE-IN 11875 to 3
===== District Five =====
Total ballots cast: 38807
Zero valid choices: 4203
One valid choice: 3850
Two valid choices: 2463
Three valid choices: 28291
* First Choice Tally
ROSS MIRKARIMI 25% 9833 <<< winner
MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 2% 851
PHILLIP HOUSE 0% 59
ROBERT HAALAND 13% 5051
EMMETT GILMAN 1% 389
JULIAN DAVIS 1% 410
LISA FELDSTEIN 8% 3207
SUSAN C. KING 2% 962
DAN KALB 3% 1383
TYS SNIFFEN 1% 678
FRANCIS SOMESEL 0% 363
JIM SIEGEL 3% 1526
PHOENIX STREETS 1% 646
ANDREW SULLIVAN 6% 2457
PATRICK M. CIOCCA 0% 86
BRETT WHEELER 2% 808
VIVIAN WILDER 0% 126
NICK WAUGH 7% 2965
ROB ANDERSON 0% 328
H. BROWN 0% 57
JOSEPH BLUE 2% 781
BILL BARNES 4% 1638
WRITE-IN 0% 0
* Any Choice Tally
ROSS MIRKARIMI 41% 16296 <<< winner
MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 6% 2499
PHILLIP HOUSE 0% 279
ROBERT HAALAND 35% 13597
EMMETT GILMAN 3% 1361
JULIAN DAVIS 4% 1575
LISA FELDSTEIN 31% 12337
SUSAN C. KING 10% 3975
DAN KALB 14% 5763
TYS SNIFFEN 6% 2451
FRANCIS SOMESEL 3% 1302
JIM SIEGEL 9% 3800
PHOENIX STREETS 6% 2399
ANDREW SULLIVAN 13% 5381
PATRICK M. CIOCCA 1% 414
BRETT WHEELER 7% 2735
VIVIAN WILDER 1% 743
NICK WAUGH 20% 7850
ROB ANDERSON 3% 1189
H. BROWN 0% 296
JOSEPH BLUE 5% 1983
BILL BARNES 13% 5421
WRITE-IN 0% 3
* Pairwise Tally
ROSS MIRKARIMI <<< winner
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 16072 to 1993
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 16287 to 193
vs. ROBERT HAALAND 14221 to 8121
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 16170 to 1041
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 16164 to 1234
vs. LISA FELDSTEIN 14701 to 6822
vs. SUSAN C. KING 15965 to 2891
vs. DAN KALB 15716 to 4470
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 16064 to 1989
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 16196 to 1163
vs. JIM SIEGEL 15920 to 3289
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 16045 to 1828
vs. ANDREW SULLIVAN 15694 to 4716
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 16270 to 342
vs. BRETT WHEELER 15994 to 2153
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 16264 to 646
vs. NICK WAUGH 15167 to 6242
vs. ROB ANDERSON 16236 to 998
vs. H. BROWN 16284 to 247
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 16125 to 1704
vs. BILL BARNES 15641 to 4323
vs. WRITE-IN 16296 to 3
MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 2491 to 220
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 2456 to 1300
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 2434 to 1463
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 2401 to 2266
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 2436 to 1250
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 2440 to 2329
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 2485 to 385
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 2478 to 706
vs. ROB ANDERSON 2444 to 1110
vs. H. BROWN 2492 to 283
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 2418 to 1937
vs. WRITE-IN 2499 to 3
PHILLIP HOUSE
vs. WRITE-IN 279 to 3
ROBERT HAALAND
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 13414 to 2268
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 13585 to 244
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 13507 to 1198
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 13507 to 1386
vs. LISA FELDSTEIN 11892 to 8049
vs. SUSAN C. KING 13334 to 3376
vs. DAN KALB 13077 to 4152
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 13451 to 2267
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 13541 to 1230
vs. JIM SIEGEL 13433 to 3545
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 13409 to 2076
vs. ANDREW SULLIVAN 13152 to 4950
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 13583 to 377
vs. BRETT WHEELER 13385 to 2432
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 13567 to 661
vs. NICK WAUGH 12682 to 6765
vs. ROB ANDERSON 13527 to 1010
vs. H. BROWN 13589 to 253
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 13439 to 1809
vs. BILL BARNES 12968 to 3844
vs. WRITE-IN 13597 to 2
EMMETT GILMAN
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 1351 to 272
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 1318 to 1270
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 1352 to 399
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 1350 to 727
vs. ROB ANDERSON 1355 to 1178
vs. H. BROWN 1355 to 283
vs. WRITE-IN 1360 to 3
JULIAN DAVIS
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 1561 to 269
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 1539 to 1323
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 1554 to 1278
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 1558 to 399
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 1549 to 721
vs. ROB ANDERSON 1511 to 1139
vs. H. BROWN 1560 to 276
vs. WRITE-IN 1575 to 2
LISA FELDSTEIN
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 12153 to 2345
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 12318 to 254
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 12194 to 1152
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 12223 to 1409
vs. SUSAN C. KING 11895 to 3129
vs. DAN KALB 11759 to 4973
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 12165 to 2245
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 12288 to 1199
vs. JIM SIEGEL 12117 to 3532
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 12129 to 2120
vs. ANDREW SULLIVAN 11816 to 4963
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 12318 to 376
vs. BRETT WHEELER 12098 to 2450
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 12295 to 610
vs. NICK WAUGH 11484 to 7046
vs. ROB ANDERSON 12284 to 1101
vs. H. BROWN 12324 to 271
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 12118 to 1783
vs. BILL BARNES 11767 to 4788
vs. WRITE-IN 12337 to 1
SUSAN C. KING
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 3829 to 2391
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 3956 to 262
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 3906 to 1316
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 3840 to 1437
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 3887 to 2389
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 3936 to 1253
vs. JIM SIEGEL 3885 to 3689
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 3844 to 2259
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 3964 to 393
vs. BRETT WHEELER 3845 to 2577
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 3923 to 613
vs. ROB ANDERSON 3884 to 1076
vs. H. BROWN 3959 to 268
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 3894 to 1942
vs. WRITE-IN 3975 to 3
DAN KALB
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 5668 to 2428
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 5760 to 262
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 5694 to 1300
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 5700 to 1490
vs. SUSAN C. KING 5490 to 3704
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 5656 to 2367
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 5701 to 1210
vs. JIM SIEGEL 5596 to 3653
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 5650 to 2276
vs. ANDREW SULLIVAN 5404 to 5149
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 5755 to 391
vs. BRETT WHEELER 5580 to 2484
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 5729 to 681
vs. ROB ANDERSON 5708 to 1102
vs. H. BROWN 5756 to 284
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 5675 to 1920
vs. BILL BARNES 5367 to 4481
vs. WRITE-IN 5763 to 3
TYS SNIFFEN
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 2450 to 270
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 2420 to 1324
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 2409 to 1545
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 2398 to 1253
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 2391 to 2336
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 2439 to 400
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 2442 to 727
vs. ROB ANDERSON 2417 to 1155
vs. H. BROWN 2448 to 285
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 2410 to 1932
vs. WRITE-IN 2451 to 3
FRANCIS SOMESEL
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 1297 to 275
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 1292 to 393
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 1281 to 727
vs. ROB ANDERSON 1300 to 1179
vs. H. BROWN 1299 to 288
vs. WRITE-IN 1302 to 3
JIM SIEGEL
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 3529 to 2226
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 3797 to 268
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 3725 to 1295
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 3752 to 1509
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 3570 to 1984
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 3689 to 1059
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 3747 to 2325
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 3780 to 378
vs. BRETT WHEELER 3718 to 2599
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 3783 to 715
vs. ROB ANDERSON 3764 to 1120
vs. H. BROWN 3791 to 281
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 3703 to 1817
vs. WRITE-IN 3800 to 3
PHOENIX STREETS
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 2392 to 262
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 2338 to 1307
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 2339 to 1520
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 2370 to 1269
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 2380 to 391
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 2376 to 694
vs. ROB ANDERSON 2346 to 1107
vs. H. BROWN 2392 to 278
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 2311 to 1922
vs. WRITE-IN 2399 to 3
ANDREW SULLIVAN
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 5263 to 2315
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 5375 to 265
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 5335 to 1297
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 5352 to 1509
vs. SUSAN C. KING 5295 to 3851
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 5218 to 1991
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 5236 to 1073
vs. JIM SIEGEL 4780 to 3214
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 5319 to 2301
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 5364 to 369
vs. BRETT WHEELER 5273 to 2533
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 5372 to 705
vs. ROB ANDERSON 5366 to 1127
vs. H. BROWN 5370 to 282
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 5262 to 1811
vs. BILL BARNES 5203 to 5142
vs. WRITE-IN 5381 to 3
PATRICK M. CIOCCA
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 410 to 278
vs. H. BROWN 408 to 294
vs. WRITE-IN 414 to 3
BRETT WHEELER
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 2668 to 2410
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 2732 to 274
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 2689 to 1311
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 2669 to 1480
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 2686 to 2414
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 2701 to 1277
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 2627 to 2300
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 2727 to 399
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 2707 to 701
vs. ROB ANDERSON 2673 to 1125
vs. H. BROWN 2724 to 287
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 2679 to 1927
vs. WRITE-IN 2735 to 3
VIVIAN WILDER
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 739 to 277
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 738 to 406
vs. H. BROWN 735 to 292
vs. WRITE-IN 743 to 3
NICK WAUGH
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 7742 to 2324
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 7844 to 266
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 7779 to 1280
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 7776 to 1420
vs. SUSAN C. KING 7619 to 3548
vs. DAN KALB 7448 to 5179
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 7666 to 2211
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 7790 to 1213
vs. JIM SIEGEL 7519 to 3471
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 7706 to 2130
vs. ANDREW SULLIVAN 6698 to 4734
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 7837 to 371
vs. BRETT WHEELER 7623 to 2411
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 7823 to 648
vs. ROB ANDERSON 7789 to 1032
vs. H. BROWN 7847 to 274
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 7727 to 1799
vs. BILL BARNES 7510 to 4958
vs. WRITE-IN 7850 to 3
ROB ANDERSON
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 1183 to 268
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 1170 to 397
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 1166 to 718
vs. H. BROWN 1179 to 274
vs. WRITE-IN 1189 to 3
H. BROWN
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 289 to 274
vs. WRITE-IN 296 to 3
JOSEPH BLUE
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 1977 to 267
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 1954 to 1312
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 1964 to 1536
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 1919 to 1248
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 1968 to 389
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 1972 to 711
vs. ROB ANDERSON 1970 to 1153
vs. H. BROWN 1978 to 281
vs. WRITE-IN 1983 to 3
BILL BARNES
vs. MICHAEL E. O'CONNOR 5356 to 2385
vs. PHILLIP HOUSE 5418 to 274
vs. EMMETT GILMAN 5364 to 1276
vs. JULIAN DAVIS 5383 to 1498
vs. SUSAN C. KING 5309 to 3745
vs. TYS SNIFFEN 5365 to 2378
vs. FRANCIS SOMESEL 5364 to 1219
vs. JIM SIEGEL 5304 to 3692
vs. PHOENIX STREETS 5304 to 2183
vs. PATRICK M. CIOCCA 5412 to 390
vs. BRETT WHEELER 5269 to 2546
vs. VIVIAN WILDER 5405 to 692
vs. ROB ANDERSON 5391 to 1138
vs. H. BROWN 5409 to 266
vs. JOSEPH BLUE 5292 to 1862
vs. WRITE-IN 5421 to 3
===== District Seven =====
Total ballots cast: 34309
Zero valid choices: 3282
One valid choice: 5307
Two valid choices: 3922
Three valid choices: 21798
* First Choice Tally
MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 2% 952
SHAWN REIFSTECK 3% 1082
CHRISTINE LINNENBACH 19% 6654
PAT LAKEY 2% 750
DAVID PARKER 0% 342
MILTON "RENNIE" O'BRIEN 6% 2310
VERNON C. GRIGG III 5% 2048
SHEELA KINI 1% 345
SVETLANA KAFF 1% 530
SEAN R. ELSBERND 30% 10320 <<< winner
GREGORY CORRALES 7% 2519
ISAAC WANG 7% 2673
ART BELENSON 1% 501
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Any Choice Tally
MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 11% 3962
SHAWN REIFSTECK 14% 4922
CHRISTINE LINNENBACH 42% 14505
PAT LAKEY 10% 3511
DAVID PARKER 5% 1965
MILTON "RENNIE" O'BRIEN 23% 8136
VERNON C. GRIGG III 18% 6515
SHEELA KINI 5% 1859
SVETLANA KAFF 5% 1801
SEAN R. ELSBERND 47% 16363 <<< winner
GREGORY CORRALES 19% 6829
ISAAC WANG 17% 5948
ART BELENSON 6% 2228
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Pairwise Tally
MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN
vs. PAT LAKEY 3815 to 3298
vs. DAVID PARKER 3826 to 1796
vs. SHEELA KINI 3909 to 1767
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 3896 to 1744
vs. ART BELENSON 3884 to 2135
vs. WRITE-IN 3962 to 1
SHAWN REIFSTECK
vs. MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 4728 to 3774
vs. PAT LAKEY 4757 to 3231
vs. DAVID PARKER 4794 to 1823
vs. SHEELA KINI 4750 to 1571
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 4840 to 1674
vs. ART BELENSON 4833 to 2110
vs. WRITE-IN 4921 to 1
CHRISTINE LINNENBACH
vs. MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 13993 to 3072
vs. SHAWN REIFSTECK 13970 to 2914
vs. PAT LAKEY 14065 to 2769
vs. DAVID PARKER 14365 to 1595
vs. MILTON "RENNIE" O'BRIEN 13404 to 6137
vs. VERNON C. GRIGG III 13211 to 4509
vs. SHEELA KINI 14361 to 1430
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 14249 to 1365
vs. GREGORY CORRALES 13401 to 5496
vs. ISAAC WANG 13743 to 5001
vs. ART BELENSON 14249 to 1643
vs. WRITE-IN 14504 to 1
PAT LAKEY
vs. DAVID PARKER 3442 to 1862
vs. SHEELA KINI 3428 to 1737
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 3462 to 1707
vs. ART BELENSON 3438 to 2147
vs. WRITE-IN 3511 to 1
DAVID PARKER
vs. SHEELA KINI 1895 to 1772
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 1851 to 1729
vs. WRITE-IN 1965 to 1
MILTON "RENNIE" O'BRIEN
vs. MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 7720 to 3446
vs. SHAWN REIFSTECK 7576 to 4391
vs. PAT LAKEY 7812 to 3151
vs. DAVID PARKER 7959 to 1701
vs. VERNON C. GRIGG III 7601 to 6079
vs. SHEELA KINI 7911 to 1471
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 7990 to 1579
vs. GREGORY CORRALES 7241 to 6027
vs. ISAAC WANG 7282 to 5378
vs. ART BELENSON 7981 to 2002
vs. WRITE-IN 8136 to 1
VERNON C. GRIGG III
vs. MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 6318 to 3664
vs. SHAWN REIFSTECK 6147 to 4445
vs. PAT LAKEY 6293 to 3196
vs. DAVID PARKER 6450 to 1825
vs. SHEELA KINI 6483 to 1789
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 6423 to 1648
vs. ISAAC WANG 6170 to 5560
vs. ART BELENSON 6396 to 2037
vs. WRITE-IN 6515 to 1
SHEELA KINI
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 1814 to 1729
vs. WRITE-IN 1859 to 1
SVETLANA KAFF
vs. WRITE-IN 1801 to 1
SEAN R. ELSBERND <<< winner
vs. MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 15974 to 2712
vs. SHAWN REIFSTECK 15807 to 3989
vs. CHRISTINE LINNENBACH 13571 to 10267
vs. PAT LAKEY 16039 to 2097
vs. DAVID PARKER 16263 to 1427
vs. MILTON "RENNIE" O'BRIEN 15376 to 5705
vs. VERNON C. GRIGG III 15232 to 4416
vs. SHEELA KINI 16283 to 1587
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 16184 to 1393
vs. GREGORY CORRALES 15389 to 4654
vs. ISAAC WANG 15576 to 4516
vs. ART BELENSON 16136 to 1426
vs. WRITE-IN 16363 to 1
GREGORY CORRALES
vs. MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 6493 to 3376
vs. SHAWN REIFSTECK 6666 to 4698
vs. PAT LAKEY 6667 to 3279
vs. DAVID PARKER 6717 to 1706
vs. VERNON C. GRIGG III 6373 to 5994
vs. SHEELA KINI 6727 to 1669
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 6700 to 1627
vs. ISAAC WANG 6390 to 5444
vs. ART BELENSON 6704 to 1956
vs. WRITE-IN 6829 to 1
ISAAC WANG
vs. MICHAEL PATRICK MALLEN 5733 to 3613
vs. SHAWN REIFSTECK 5710 to 4611
vs. PAT LAKEY 5780 to 3312
vs. DAVID PARKER 5822 to 1699
vs. SHEELA KINI 5832 to 1529
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 5815 to 1668
vs. ART BELENSON 5841 to 2009
vs. WRITE-IN 5948 to 1
ART BELENSON
vs. DAVID PARKER 2170 to 1898
vs. SHEELA KINI 2188 to 1804
vs. SVETLANA KAFF 2165 to 1758
vs. WRITE-IN 2228 to 1
===== District Nine =====
Total ballots cast: 25897
Zero valid choices: 1489
One valid choice: 4227
Two valid choices: 4147
Three valid choices: 16034
* First Choice Tally
STEVE ZELTZER 3% 790
JAMES BORIS PEREZ 2% 565
RENEE SAUCEDO 20% 5399
TOM AMMIANO 47% 12395 <<< winner
LUCRECIA BERMUDEZ 3% 1006
MIGUEL BUSTOS 16% 4251
WRITE-IN 0% 2
* Any Choice Tally
STEVE ZELTZER 12% 3211
JAMES BORIS PEREZ 10% 2733
RENEE SAUCEDO 62% 16298
TOM AMMIANO 71% 18534 <<< winner
LUCRECIA BERMUDEZ 26% 6825
MIGUEL BUSTOS 50% 13016
WRITE-IN 0% 6
* Pairwise Tally
STEVE ZELTZER
vs. JAMES BORIS PEREZ 2922 to 2196
vs. WRITE-IN 3211 to 6
JAMES BORIS PEREZ
vs. WRITE-IN 2733 to 5
RENEE SAUCEDO
vs. STEVE ZELTZER 15803 to 2301
vs. JAMES BORIS PEREZ 15968 to 2146
vs. LUCRECIA BERMUDEZ 15045 to 3122
vs. MIGUEL BUSTOS 12891 to 7982
vs. WRITE-IN 16296 to 3
TOM AMMIANO <<< winner
vs. STEVE ZELTZER 18168 to 1735
vs. JAMES BORIS PEREZ 18216 to 1789
vs. RENEE SAUCEDO 14468 to 7762
vs. LUCRECIA BERMUDEZ 17778 to 3243
vs. MIGUEL BUSTOS 15948 to 6787
vs. WRITE-IN 18534 to 3
LUCRECIA BERMUDEZ
vs. STEVE ZELTZER 6611 to 2973
vs. JAMES BORIS PEREZ 6613 to 2472
vs. WRITE-IN 6823 to 6
MIGUEL BUSTOS
vs. STEVE ZELTZER 12484 to 2330
vs. JAMES BORIS PEREZ 12515 to 1672
vs. LUCRECIA BERMUDEZ 11849 to 5059
vs. WRITE-IN 13016 to 5
===== District Eleven =====
Total ballots cast: 24700
Zero valid choices: 1817
One valid choice: 4490
Two valid choices: 2053
Three valid choices: 16340
* First Choice Tally
JOSE MEDINA 11% 2834
MYRNA VIRAY LIM 17% 4218
ANITA GRIER 11% 2766
FIL M. SILVERIO 1% 307
REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG 7% 1801
GERARDO SANDOVAL 29% 7376 <<< winner
ROLANDO A. BONIALLA 9% 2267
TOM YUEN 5% 1313
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Any Choice Tally
JOSE MEDINA 37% 9346
MYRNA VIRAY LIM 37% 9346
ANITA GRIER 33% 8196
FIL M. SILVERIO 6% 1490
REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG 24% 6161
GERARDO SANDOVAL 49% 12202 <<< winner
ROLANDO A. BONIALLA 25% 6411
TOM YUEN 18% 4463
WRITE-IN 0% 1
* Pairwise Tally
JOSE MEDINA
vs. ANITA GRIER 7972 to 6624
vs. FIL M. SILVERIO 9219 to 1198
vs. REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG 8340 to 4952
vs. ROLANDO A. BONIALLA 7990 to 4928
vs. TOM YUEN 8922 to 3941
vs. WRITE-IN 9345 to 1
MYRNA VIRAY LIM
vs. JOSE MEDINA 8162 to 7858
vs. ANITA GRIER 7999 to 6388
vs. FIL M. SILVERIO 9211 to 1038
vs. REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG 8390 to 4978
vs. ROLANDO A. BONIALLA 8468 to 5446
vs. TOM YUEN 8389 to 2877
vs. WRITE-IN 9346 to 1
ANITA GRIER
vs. FIL M. SILVERIO 8035 to 1261
vs. REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG 7029 to 4933
vs. ROLANDO A. BONIALLA 7556 to 5856
vs. TOM YUEN 7350 to 3539
vs. WRITE-IN 8196 to 1
FIL M. SILVERIO
vs. WRITE-IN 1490 to 1
REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG
vs. FIL M. SILVERIO 6027 to 1336
vs. TOM YUEN 5848 to 4127
vs. WRITE-IN 6161 to 1
GERARDO SANDOVAL <<< winner
vs. JOSE MEDINA 10561 to 5779
vs. MYRNA VIRAY LIM 10534 to 7532
vs. ANITA GRIER 11111 to 6162
vs. FIL M. SILVERIO 12057 to 1146
vs. REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG 11454 to 4501
vs. ROLANDO A. BONIALLA 11083 to 4043
vs. TOM YUEN 11732 to 3517
vs. WRITE-IN 12202 to 1
ROLANDO A. BONIALLA
vs. FIL M. SILVERIO 6317 to 1307
vs. REBECCA REYNOLDS SILVERBERG 5758 to 5447
vs. TOM YUEN 6270 to 4125
vs. WRITE-IN 6410 to 1
TOM YUEN
vs. FIL M. SILVERIO 4331 to 1280
vs. WRITE-IN 4463 to 1
Copyright 2004 by Justin T. Sampson